Orioles Consensus top prospect

I put together an Orioles Consensus Top Prospect List using 12 different prospect rankings. 20 different players appeared on these various lists. These lists include national publications such as Baseball America, Baseball Prospectus, and Fangraphs. They also include lists from Orioles focused publications such as Orioles Hangout, Baltimore Baseball (Dean Jones), and Baby Birdland. I only used the top 10 ranked players from each list because the lists are of different lengths, but every list has at least 10 players. I did use the rankings past 10 when available to break any ties. Following the consensus list, I listed each of the top tens and linked the source site (Baseball America is now behind a paywall).

  1. Austin Hays (Range: 1-2)
  2. Chance Sisco (1-4)
  3. Ryan Mountcastle (1-7)
  4. Hunter Harvey (3-6)
  5. DL Hall (2-7)
  6. Cedric Mullins (5-NR)
  7. Tanner Scott (4-NR)
  8. Keegan Akin (7-NR)
  9. DJ Stewart (5-NR)
  10. Anthony Santander (8-NR)
  11. Alex Wells (7-NR)
  12. Cody Sedlock (7-NR)
  13. Brenan Hanifee (6-NR)
  14. Michael Baumann (6-NR)
  15. Cameron Bishop (7-NR)
  16. Zac Lowther* (9-NR)
  17. Jomar Reyes* (8-NR)
  18. Adam Hall* (8-NR)
  19. Matthias Dietz (9-NR)
  20. Chris Lee (10-NR)

* denotes a tie

Baseball America Baseball Prospectus Prospects 1500 Orioles Hangout Luke John Sickels
Hays Mountcastle Hays Hays Hays Hays
Mountcastle Hays Sisco Mountcastle Sisco Mountcastle
Sisco DL Hall Harvey Harvey Mountcastle Sisco
Harvey Sisco Mountcastle Sisco Harvey Harvey
DL Hall Mullins DL Hall DL Hall DL Hall DL Hall
Scott Harvey Mullins Stewart Mullins Baumann
Sedlock Akin Scott Wells Stewart Scott
Santander Stewart Adam Hall Santander Akin Mullins
Mullins Lowther Akin Akin Wells Santander
Lee Scott Santander Mullins Scott Stewart
Keith Law Dean Jones prospect361 MLB Pipeline Baby Birdland Fangraphs
Sisco Hays Hays Hays Hays Hays
Hays Mountcastle DL Hall Mountcastle Sisco Sisco
Mountcastle Sisco Sisco Sisco Mountcastle Harvey
Harvey Harvey Harvey Harvey Scott DL Hall
DL Hall Mullins Stewart DL Hall Mullins Scott
Hanifee Scott Mountcastle Scott Harvey Mullins
Bishop DL Hall Akin Mullins Akin Mountcastle
Mullins Stewart Reyes Santander DL Hall Sedlock
Akin Akin Wells Akin Stewart Dietz
Scott Santander Scott Hanifee Santander Lowther

 

 

SHARE
Previous articleOrioles Minor League Game Summaries 4/11
Next articleOrioles Minor League Game Summaries 4/12
Tony has owned and operated Orioles Hangout since 1996 and is well known for his knowledge of the Baltimore Orioles organization from top to bottom. He's a frequent guest on Baltimore-area sports radio stations and can be heard regularly on the 105.7 FM The Fan. His knowledge and contacts within the Orioles minor league system and the major league baseball scouting industry is unparalleled in the Baltimore media and is known as an expert on the Orioles prospects.